HomeProductUse casesPricingBlogContactSign in Book a demo

Blog

Data extraction: machine learning vs. template-based solutions

Last updated:

What is data extraction?

Data extraction means collecting information from documents and other unstructured sources, converting it and storing it in a structured format so that other systems can process or analyse it.

What types of data extraction are there?

There are two common approaches, and each suits different situations.

Traditional template solutions

A template solution works with predefined templates or rules. Extraction only works if the document follows the pattern or format the template expects, and someone has to create and maintain those templates by hand. That takes time. Such solutions work best with well-structured documents in a consistent format.

The technology behind them is OCR (optical character recognition). It was originally developed to turn written characters into speech for blind people and was later used to recognise black text on a white background. The more varied the documents, the worse it works: a conventional OCR engine is set up with templates and cannot keep up with a wide range of documents.

One scenario where this approach can work well is a company with a small number of 5–10 fixed suppliers whose invoices and documents rarely change structure. In that case you can build templates for those suppliers and use an automated program to extract the information you need.

But industrial companies often work with many different suppliers, and suppliers change frequently. The templates then constantly lag behind changes in processes and document structures.

Every new supplier and every format change means creating or updating a template. With many suppliers, that maintenance becomes a permanent job.

Modern machine learning solutions

Modern machine learning solutions, by contrast, need no predefined templates. The model is trained to recognise patterns and structures in the data itself, so it can extract data from very different sources and formats.

Machine learning solutions extract data with high accuracy, leave less manual work and make fewer errors. They grow with document volume and can be adapted to new document types without setting up a new project each time.

How does data extraction with templates work?

In template-based data extraction, a template with fixed rules is defined for each document format. The system only finds the data if the document follows that pattern. The templates are created and maintained by hand.

How does data extraction with machine learning work?

Data extraction with machine learning has no hand-written rules. First the data is prepared, then a model is trained to recognise patterns and relationships. Finally, the model is checked for accuracy.

Once validated, the model extracts information from new documents automatically. It keeps being adjusted in day-to-day use and so covers new requirements as well.

What is the difference between extraction with ML and with templates?

Machine learning (ML) recognises patterns, adapts and improves with the data, without every rule having to be programmed by hand.

A template only works for the format it was built for and cannot adapt. An ML model reads documents in very different formats, and more precisely.

When should you use machine learning for data extraction?

Machine learning for data extraction pays off above all when there are many documents, when their structure is complicated or when results have to be very accurate.

When requirements change, the model adapts, and the extraction results improve over time.

Send us a document and watch the extraction.

30 minutes, your own documents, no preparation needed.